Inside My Mentor Coaching Sessions: What ACC Coaches Are Working on Right Now
Inside My Mentor Coaching Sessions: What ACC Coaches Are Working on Right Now
I’ve been doing a lot of recording reviews lately, and I thought it might be useful to share some of what I’m actually noticing and talking about with coaches in mentor coaching.
One of the things I love most about this work is that the development is rarely about learning another complicated coaching technique. More often, it’s about helping a coach hear something in their own coaching that they couldn’t quite see while they were in the session.
Sometimes it’s, “Your first question was excellent. Trust it more.”
Sometimes it’s, “Ask more, tell less.”
Sometimes we’re looking at whether the coach is staying with the client’s language or moving too quickly into their own interpretation. Other times we’re noticing that the client has just had a really meaningful insight and the coach is already racing toward, “So what are you going to do about that?”
The conversations are incredibly specific to the coach in front of me, but there are definitely themes I’m hearing across recordings right now.
All of the examples in this article are anonymized. In some cases I’ve combined similar themes I’ve seen across several coaching sessions so that no individual coach or client is identifiable.
What a Recording Review With Me Actually Looks Like
When we’re doing a recording review, you send me a real coaching session ahead of time. I usually have the recording and transcript, and I go through the session before we meet.
I’m not listening for a list of everything you did “wrong.” I’m listening for evidence.
Where did you create space for the client to think? Where did you use their language really beautifully? Where did something shift? Where did the client create new awareness? Where did you possibly move ahead of them, add your own meaning, solve something for them, or move past something that might have been worth staying with?
I’ll often pull out very specific moments so that instead of saying, “I think you might be a bit directive,” we can actually go back to the moment and look at what happened.
What did the client say?
What did you hear?
What made you ask the question you asked?
What did your response create?
What else might have been possible?
That gives us something real to work with.
And when we meet, I don’t want to jump straight into my feedback. I want to hear what you noticed first.
I’ll often ask questions like, “What stood out to you when you listened back?” “What felt really strong?” “Where did you feel less certain?” “What are you most curious about?” or “What would be most useful for us to focus on?”
Your own reflection matters. This isn’t me assessing you from across the table. It’s a collaborative learning process.
“Your First Question Is Usually Enough.”
This has probably been one of my most repeated pieces of feedback lately.
A coach asks a really strong question…and then keeps going.
They explain what they mean. They add some context. They ask another version of the same question. Then they add a second question just in case.
And the funny thing is, when we listen back together, the first question was usually the strongest one.
So I’ve been saying a lot:
Trust your first question more.
Or even:
The first question is usually enough.
I don’t think this comes from coaches not knowing how to ask good questions. Usually it’s the opposite. They’ve already asked a really thoughtful question, but there’s this tiny moment of uncertainty afterward where they feel like they need to help the client understand it.
That’s where I’ll encourage them to do less.
Ask the question. Stop talking. Let the client think.
For one coach recently, this has become a really clear developmental theme: shorter, more intentional questions. And what has been so fun is hearing the shift in the next recording. There was more space, and the client was doing more of the work.
That means the next conversation changes too. We’re no longer just talking about shortening questions. Now we can ask, “When you create that space, what are you noticing the client doing with it?”
That’s the part of mentor coaching I love. The work keeps moving.
“Ask More, Tell Less.”
This is another phrase I’ve used a lot lately.
And I don’t mean coaches are sitting there openly telling clients what to do. Often it’s much subtler than that.
It can sound like:
“I think what you’re realizing is…”
or
“It sounds like these two things are connected because…”
or a really thoughtful summary where the coach has actually done quite a lot of the meaning-making for the client.
Sometimes the interpretation is completely right. That still doesn’t necessarily mean we should be the one making it.
One question I’ve come back to in recording reviews is:
Am I helping the client think, or am I thinking for the client?
That can be such a useful filter.
Instead of deciding that two things are connected, perhaps we ask:
“Is it the same thing, or are there different things here? Are they connected?”
Now the client gets to decide.
One coach I’ve worked with is already naturally very strong at listening, reflecting and creating space. Their next edge wasn’t to become a “better listener.” It was resisting the pull to become the person who solves the problem.
That distinction matters.
We’re always building from what is already strong.
Stay With the Client’s Language
I pay a lot of attention to the words clients choose.
Sometimes there is one word in a session that carries so much meaning, and the coach moves right past it because they’re already thinking about the next question.
This is one of the reasons listening back to recordings is so useful. You suddenly hear things that were easy to miss while you were coaching.
Maybe the client says, “I think I just want some space.”
And the coach immediately asks what action they want to take.
But the interesting word may not be action at all.
It may be space.
What does space mean to this client?
What does it give them?
What would change if they had it?
What happens when they don’t?
That is where I’ll often encourage a coach to stay with the client’s vocabulary rather than translating it into their own language.
You don’t always need a more sophisticated question.
Sometimes the client has already given you the question.
Coach the Source, Not Just the Symptom
This is another phrase I use in mentor coaching:
Coach the source, not the symptom.
Clients often come in with something very practical. Their calendar is too full. They need to make a decision. They’re struggling with a colleague. They want to have a difficult conversation.
It is very easy for the coaching to become entirely about solving the problem.
Sometimes that is what the client wants, and we don’t need to force depth where it isn’t needed.
But sometimes there is something underneath the problem that the client is already pointing toward.
I remember one recording where the conversation was about a full calendar. A very practical problem. But the more interesting question became:
“What does a full calendar give you?”
That moves us somewhere completely different.
Now we’re not just rearranging appointments. We’re learning something about the person.
That is often where I’m inviting coaches to become curious about the who, not only the what.
You might hear me ask:
“What have you noticed about yourself in this conversation?”
or
“That’s who you want to be. And who are you being right now?”
Those questions aren’t better because they’re deeper or more impressive. They’re useful when they help the client understand something about themselves that changes how they see the situation.
Let the Insight Breathe Before You Turn It Into an Action Plan
I hear this all the time.
The client suddenly sees something differently.
There’s a pause.
You can almost hear the moment land.
And then the coach says:
“Great. So what’s your first step?”
There is nothing wrong with asking about action. We absolutely want coaching to support meaningful forward movement.
But sometimes we get there too quickly.
One of the questions I’ve been inviting coaches to ask themselves is:
Did I evoke meaningful awareness but rush through what happened next?
Sometimes we need to let the learning settle first.
What changed?
What are they noticing?
What does this mean?
What do they want to take from what they’ve discovered?
Then we can ask what they want to do with it.
I think there’s a big difference between moving a client into action because we feel like we’re supposed to end with an action step, and helping the client decide what they genuinely want to do with what they’ve learned.
Let the Client Own the Accountability Too
This connects closely to another theme I’ve been working on lately: accountability without dependency.
A client decides they are going to do something, and naturally the coach wants to help them follow through.
So we offer an accountability structure.
Should I check in with you?
Could you put it in your calendar?
Could you tell someone?
Again, those aren’t bad ideas.
But I’m interested in whether the client could design the accountability themselves.
“How will you support yourself in following through?”
“What could get in the way?”
“What would help you stay connected to this?”
“How do you want to hold yourself accountable?”
I want the client leaving the coaching relationship more able to trust themselves, not more reliant on the coach to keep them moving.
That’s a really interesting thing to listen for in your own recordings.
Who is carrying the accountability?
Sometimes We Need to Re-Contract
Another thing I notice in recordings is how easily a conversation can move away from the original agreement.
This happens all the time because coaching is dynamic. The client starts talking, something new comes up, and suddenly there are three different directions available.
The issue isn’t that the conversation shifted.
The question is whether the coach quietly decided which direction to follow.
Sometimes I’ll pause a recording and say, “There are a few really interesting threads here. How did you decide which one to take?”
That gives us a chance to talk about partnership.
In the actual coaching session, that might sound like:
“We’ve uncovered a few different directions. Which one feels most important to stay with?”
Or:
“We started with X, and I’m noticing we’ve moved toward Y. What would be most useful for you now?”
You don’t have to hold the entire map yourself.
Invite the client to help you find the way forward.
The Goal Isn’t to Give You 20 Things to Fix
When I review a recording, I might notice a lot.
That does not mean I think it’s useful to hand you a list of 20 things to work on.
I would much rather identify one or two experiments that could have the biggest impact.
Maybe the experiment is:
Ask one clear question at a time.
Maybe it’s:
When you notice emotion, stay there a little longer.
Maybe it’s:
Notice when you begin interpreting and hand the discovery back to the client.
Then go coach.
Try it.
See what happens.
And bring that reflection back.
I’ll often ask a coach in the next session:
What did you experiment with? What did you notice?
The time between mentor coaching sessions is part of the learning process. You need time to actually apply the feedback with real clients.
What It Feels Like to Work With Me
I think the simplest way to describe my approach is that I want mentor coaching to be specific, honest and useful.
I will tell you what I see.
If there is a pattern in your coaching that I think is getting in your way, we are going to talk about it.
But we’re also going to talk about what is already working.
I want you to know what your strengths are because those are often the exact things we can build from.
And I want the feedback to be grounded in evidence. Not “You seem too directive.” More like, “At the 14-minute mark, notice what the client says here. Now listen to what happens immediately afterward.”
Then we can think together.
I’m also not looking for magic phrases or one “correct” way to coach. I don’t want you leaving mentor coaching sounding like me.
Your natural coaching style matters.
My job is to help you hear your coaching more clearly, understand the impact you are having and make intentional choices about what you want to develop next.
Want to Try a Mini Recording Review Yourself?
If you have permission to record your coaching, pull up one recent session and choose about 10–15 minutes.
You don’t need to assess the entire session.
Listen and ask yourself:
Where did I follow the client’s language, energy and thinking?
Where did the client generate new awareness?
What happened immediately before that awareness?
What did I do immediately afterward?
Where did I ask one clean question and give the client space?
Where did I add context I probably didn’t need?
Where did I begin interpreting, advising or solving?
Whose curiosity was driving my questions?
Where could I have stayed with something a little longer?
And then, rather than creating a huge improvement plan, choose one thing.
One experiment for your next client.
That is very close to how I want mentor coaching to feel.
Notice.
Choose.
Practise.
Come back.
See what changed.
Looking for Private ACC Renewal Mentor Coaching?
I offer one-to-one mentor coaching for ACC renewal and hold the ICF Mentor Coach Specialization at both the ACC and PCC levels, along with my ICF PCC credential and PCC Marker Assessor training.
My full package includes 10 private 60-minute mentor coaching sessions completed over the required minimum three-month period.
Recording review is a big part of how I work. You send me selected real coaching sessions, I listen ahead of time and organize competency-based feedback before we meet. Then our live time can be spent actually thinking together about your coaching rather than simply listening to the recording.
You can see the details & pricing here if you want more info.
If you have already completed seven qualifying group mentor coaching hours and only need the three required private hours, I also offer a 3-Hour Private Mentor Coaching Package.
If you’re wondering whether my approach would be the right fit for you, these may also be helpful:
WHAT QUESTIONS SHOULD I ASK AN ICF MENTOR COACH BEFORE HIRING THEM?
HOW DO I FIND AN ICF MCS MENTOR COACH FOR ACC RENEWAL IN 2027?
And if you’re ready to talk:
The examples in this article have been anonymized and, where appropriate, combine recurring developmental themes from multiple mentor coaching engagements. No identifying client information has been included.