Coaching Skills Development: 6 Questions I’m Asking Coaches Right Now

Coaching Skills Development: 6 Questions I’m Asking Coaches Right Now

I facilitated a group mentor coaching session this week for the coaching program I work for, and we ended up having the kind of conversation I love because we weren’t talking about coaching skills in the abstract. We were talking about real moments that come up when you’re sitting across from an actual client and have to decide what to do next.

How do you coach someone who feels deeply wronged without getting pulled into deciding whether they were actually wronged? How do you develop your own coaching style when you’re still consciously thinking about competencies and techniques? How much structure should you bring into a first session? What do you do with a belief like “I’m not good enough”? Can you be fully yourself and still be a professional coach? And what actually makes a strong ending to a coaching session?

I left thinking the questions themselves were worth sharing.

These aren’t six rules for better coaching, and I don’t think there is one perfect answer to most of them. They are the kinds of questions I think help us become more intentional about the choices we’re making as coaches.

They also connect strongly to the current ICF Core Competencies, particularly around client autonomy, presence, listening, evoking awareness and partnering with clients to turn learning into growth.

So, here are six coaching skills development questions I’m thinking about right now — along with my own take on each one.

1. What Feels Coachable Here — And What Do I Need to Be Careful Not to Get Pulled Into?

One of the cases we explored involved a client who felt deeply wronged by a decision that had been made. They had challenged the decision, nothing had changed, and they were continuing to think about it over and over again.

The interesting coaching question for me wasn’t:

Was the decision actually unfair?

As a coach, I don't necessarily need to solve that question.

I can believe that the client genuinely experienced something as hurtful and unfair without joining them in building the case for why everyone else was wrong.

That distinction matters.

My curiosity would move toward: What is the client making this mean? What choices do they believe they have now? What emotions still need some space? What part of this experience is actually within their control?

One of the questions I brought into the group was:

What would help this client regain a sense of agency?

Because once something has happened that we cannot change, continuing to prove that it shouldn't have happened may not be where the most useful coaching lives.

I might ask a client what they feel their choices are now. I might make room for the anger or disappointment instead of immediately trying to move them past it. And once we had explored that, I might ask something like:

“If this were a chapter in the book of your life, what would an incredible ending to this chapter look like? How could you begin creating that?”

That doesn’t require the client to decide the situation was okay.

It helps them decide what they want to do with it.

My take here is that good coaching does not require us to either agree with the client's story or talk them out of it. Sometimes our job is to help them understand what the experience means to them and where they still have choice.

For your own reflection, think about a client whose version of events you found yourself strongly agreeing with — or strongly disagreeing with. Did your reaction change where you took the coaching? Were you helping the client establish who was right, or helping them decide who they wanted to be next?

2. Which Parts of My Coaching Actually Feel Like Me?

We also spent time talking about something that I think almost every developing coach eventually has to work through: finding your own coaching style.

When you’re learning to coach, there is naturally a lot of borrowing.

You learn a question from an instructor and try it. You see another coach do something beautifully and think, I want to do that. You learn a framework and lean heavily on the framework because it gives you somewhere to go.

I don’t think there is anything wrong with that. It is part of learning.

But eventually I think it becomes useful to ask:

Which parts of my coaching genuinely feel like me, and which parts still feel like I’m borrowing someone else’s language or technique?

I can see this evolution really clearly in my own coaching.

I’m a very organized person. I love a process. I love a system. Give me something messy and I naturally want to figure out how all the pieces fit together.

Earlier in my coaching, I brought much more of that into the room. I spent a lot of time coaching the what.

  • What are we going to do?

  • What's the plan?

  • What's the next step?

  • How do we organize this?

Those things still have a place in my coaching. They are genuinely part of who I am.

But as I’ve developed as a coach, I’ve become much more interested in coaching the who.

  • Who is this person being right now?

  • How much of that is intentional?

  • Who do they want to become?

  • What would need to shift for them to become that version of themselves?

  • And how willing are they to make those changes?

That shift has made my coaching feel much more like mine.

My take is that your coaching style isn't your favourite tool, framework or list of powerful questions. It is much closer to the way you naturally listen, what you notice, what you become curious about and how clients experience themselves when they are with you.

One of the questions I gave the group is one I think is worth sitting with:

Finish this sentence: “I think clients experience me as a coach who…”

Don't answer it with what you hope they experience. Think about your actual coaching. What feedback do you hear repeatedly? What do clients seem to trust you with? What kind of moments do you naturally notice? What parts of your coaching would still sound like you if I took away every framework you had learned?

3. How Much Structure Does a First Coaching Session Actually Need?

Another conversation was about the first coaching session.

I think this is an interesting one because there are risks at both ends.

If there is too little structure, the client may leave without a clear sense of what coaching is, what they want from the work or how the relationship is going to support them.

But I also think we can over-structure first sessions.

We have our intake questions. Our coaching agreement. Our assessment. Our worksheet. Our process. Our list of things we have decided need to happen before the "real coaching" can begin.

And suddenly we're working our way through our agenda instead of paying attention to the person sitting in front of us.

Personally, I often use a Wheel of Life exercise in an initial coaching session. I like it because it gives me a broader view of how a client thinks about their life, but more importantly, it gives the client an opportunity to see their life from a slightly different perspective.

They may notice that something they thought was an isolated problem is affecting several areas. They may see that an area they assumed needed the most work actually isn't where they want to put their energy. It gives us information, but I don't want the tool itself to become the point of the session.

That's an important distinction.

My take is that structure should support the coaching conversation, not become the coaching conversation.

I want enough structure that the client understands what we're doing together and we have a meaningful agreement. But I also want enough flexibility that if something important walks into the room with them, we're able to respond to it.

A question I asked the group was:

“If you had 60 minutes with a brand-new client tomorrow, what would you want the first 15 minutes to accomplish?”

I think that's a more useful question than simply asking what questions should be on your intake form.

What does this particular client need to understand, experience or decide in order for the coaching relationship to begin well?

4. What If Trying to Change a Limiting Belief Is the Wrong First Move?

We also talked about a very familiar coaching statement:

“I'm not good enough.”

There can be such a strong instinct as a coach to immediately help the client see that this isn't true.

We want to find the evidence.

Look at everything you've accomplished.

Look at the people who believe in you.

Of course you're good enough.

And I understand the instinct because we want to help.

But my take is that I don't think our first job is to win an argument against the client's limiting belief.

I'm much more interested in understanding it.

When does this belief tend to show up most strongly?

What does believing “I'm not good enough” protect you from or help you avoid?

What does the belief cost you when you listen to it?

What evidence in your life doesn't quite fit with the belief?

And one of my favourite questions from our discussion:

“If you didn't have to organize your choices around this belief, who might you be or what might become possible?”

That's very different from me saying:

“Here's why you're good enough.”

One approach asks the client to accept my interpretation.

The other gives them space to understand their own.

I also think the word protect is worth paying attention to here. A belief that appears irrational from the outside can sometimes be doing an incredibly logical job.

If believing “I'm not good enough” stops me from applying, I don't have to risk rejection.

If it stops me from speaking up, I don't have to risk being criticized.

If it stops me from trying something new, I don't have to find out whether I can actually do it.

That doesn't mean we need to keep the belief.

But understanding what it has been doing for the client can be much more useful than trying to tear it down immediately.

For your own reflection, think about what happens inside you when a client says something harsh about themselves. How quickly do you want to reassure them? What would become possible if you got curious before trying to make them feel better?

5. Can I Be Fully Myself and Still Be a Professional Coach?

This might have been my favourite conversation of the session.

The question was essentially: Do I need to suppress or restrict parts of myself in order to be a professional coach?

I think newer coaches can feel this tension especially strongly.

You're thinking about the competencies. You're trying not to lead. You're remembering your agreements. You're wondering whether you're talking too much. You're trying to listen properly. You're noticing that you really want to give advice and reminding yourself to stay curious instead.

It can start to feel like there is a version of you who exists naturally, and then there is this more restricted version called Professional Coach that you are supposed to perform when the Zoom call starts.

I don't think that's the goal.

The reframe I offered in the group was that it's less:

“A professional coach wouldn't say or do this, so I need to suppress myself.”

And more:

“I have access to all of myself. What part of me is most useful to bring forward here?”

That feels very different to me.

I'm not trying to become less myself.

I'm becoming more intentional about how I use myself in service of the client.

Sometimes my warmth is useful.

Sometimes my directness is useful.

Sometimes my humour is useful.

Sometimes I have a really good idea — and the most useful thing I can do with that idea is not say it, because the client is still discovering something of their own.

That isn't inauthentic.

It's a choice.

One of the questions we played with was:

Can authenticity include restraint?

I think it absolutely can.

And I also think this gets easier with time. Early in your development, the skills can feel very conscious. You're actively thinking about questions and competencies and boundaries and whether you're leading.

As those skills become more integrated, there is often more room for your personality, not less.

The structure starts to feel less like a costume and more like something you can move naturally inside.

So rather than asking, “Am I allowed to be myself as a coach?”, I think a more interesting reflection is: What parts of me make me a more effective coach when they're fully available — and how do I choose when bringing them forward actually serves the client?

6. What Actually Makes a Strong Coaching Session Close?

We finished the group talking about something I'm seeing quite a bit of opportunity around right now: how coaches close their sessions.

The final five or ten minutes can easily become a checklist.

What did you learn?

What's your action step?

When will you do it?

How will you hold yourself accountable?

Anything else?

And done.

Those are all reasonable questions, but I want the end of a coaching session to feel like the client is integrating what just happened, not like the coach has suddenly started racing through the required closing sequence.

I've been sharing a simple process with some of my 1:1 mentor coaching clients, and when I looked at the words together, I realized they conveniently spell CLOSER.

The CLOSER Framework is: Capture the learning. Locate the progress. Own the next step. Support and troubleshoot. Establish personal accountability. Round out the session.

Capture the learning means giving the client room to name what they are taking from the conversation in their own words. I'm less interested in giving them my summary of what I think they learned and more interested in hearing what actually landed for them.

Locate the progress is about helping the client recognize where something shifted. Maybe their thinking changed. Maybe they made a decision. Maybe the original problem is still there, but they are relating to it differently. I want them to be able to see what changed during the conversation.

Own the next step means the action belongs to the client. Not, “Here's what I think you should do next.” What do they want to do with what they've discovered?

Then I want to support and troubleshoot. What might get in the way? What support would be useful? What do they already know about themselves that we should account for?

From there we can establish personal accountability. Again, I don't want to automatically become the accountability system. I may ask, “How do you want to hold yourself accountable to this?” rather than immediately offering to check in.

And finally, round out the session. Let the client have some say in how this conversation finishes. What feels complete? Is there anything they want to name before we close? How do they want to leave the conversation?

To me, the strongest closing sequence doesn't feel like six separate steps the coach is forcing the client through. It feels like a natural integration of the work they've just done.

The reflection I would leave you with here is: When you're closing a coaching session, are you helping the client integrate their learning — or are you trying to make sure you've asked all the closing questions?

Coaching Skills Development Isn't About Collecting More Questions

One of the things I love about mentor coaching is that we're rarely searching for the one perfect question someone should have asked.

We're slowing the coaching down enough to notice what happened.

Why did you ask that?

What were you responding to?

What did the client do next?

Where were you genuinely curious?

Where did you start carrying the work for them?

Where did you trust yourself?

Where did you trust the client?

And what do you want to experiment with next time?

That's coaching skills development to me.

It isn't memorizing fifty more powerful questions. It's developing enough awareness of yourself, the client and the coaching relationship that you become increasingly intentional about the choices you're making in the room.

I think that's also why listening to your actual coaching is so useful. A question like “Do I give my clients enough space?” becomes much more interesting when we can listen to a real session together and see what happened after you asked the question.

If you'd like a closer look at how I do that, I shared several real anonymized examples in Inside My ICF Mentor Coaching Sessions: What ACC Coaches Are Working on Right Now.

Want to Develop Your Coaching With a Second Set of Ears?

I'm an ICF PCC and hold the ICF Mentor Coach Specialization at both the ACC and PCC levels, along with PCC Marker Assessor training.

My mentor coaching is highly developmental and recording-based. For selected sessions, you send me real coaching ahead of time. I listen, pull out specific moments and prepare competency-based feedback so that when we meet, we can spend our time actually thinking together about your coaching.

Sometimes the feedback is a very specific skill.

Sometimes it's a pattern.

Sometimes it's a question you hadn't thought to ask yourself yet.

And quite often, it's helping you recognize something you're already doing really well so we can figure out how to do more of it intentionally.

If you're completing your ACC renewal and want to use those required mentor coaching hours as an opportunity to genuinely develop your coaching, you can see my private ACC Renewal Mentor Coaching packages here.

And if what you've read here has you curious about what I might hear in your coaching, you can apply to work with me here.

The coaching situations referenced in this article come from themes explored in group and individual mentor coaching. Details have been anonymized and, where appropriate, generalized to protect the privacy of the coaches and clients involved.

Justine Cochrane